WASHINGTON — The Home handed a pair of payments Wednesday repealing cashless bail in DC and far of a legislation handed by the town’s council in 2022 that restricted cops’ use of drive — together with banning chokeholds — and their capability to collectively negotiate disciplinary actions in opposition to them.
The primary measure, launched by Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-NY), would mandate pretrial and post-conviction detention for harmful or violent crimes and require obligatory money bail for offenders who pose a menace to public security within the nation’s capital — and it handed in a 237-179 vote.
The opposite piece of laws eliminating the DC Council’s Complete Policing and Justice Reform Modification Act of 2022 sailed by the Home in a 233-190 vote.
Stefanik described her invoice as a “precursor” to an effort geared toward scrapping New York’s “failed bail reform.”
“New Yorkers know that Kathy Hochul’s failed bail reform has unleashed a criminal offense wave throughout our state by emboldening violent criminals and placing law-abiding New Yorkers in hurt’s manner,” Stefanik advised The Put up. “Kathy Hochul’s failed bail reform has actually brought on murders, assaults, rapes, and heinous crimes to be dedicated in opposition to law-abiding New Yorkers.”
“Immediately I proudly voted to finish cashless bail in DC, which Congress has jurisdiction over, and this can be a precursor to subsequent month when Congress will move my invoice to finish New York’s failed bail reform,” she added. “Kathy Hochul is incapable of creating New York protected, so I’ll come excessive of her and move this in Congress.”
Republicans rallied behind Stefanik’s invoice, however Democrats claimed DC’s present guidelines for pretrial launch largely matched federal legislation, making the measure pointless.
“Her invoice isn’t simply unconstitutional; it runs immediately in opposition to one of many bedrock ideas of our justice system: The accused are presumed harmless till confirmed responsible in a court docket of legislation,” mentioned Delegate Eleanor Holmes Norton, a Democrat who represents the District in Congress.
“Progressive, activist judges are at present allowed to launch criminals to DC’s streets with solely a promise that they won’t re-offend and can return to court docket for his or her trial date,” mentioned Rep. James Comer (R-Ky.) throughout flooring debate on the laws.
“The DC Money Bail Reform Act would take away a choose’s capability to launch these violent criminals. It could require judges to carry anybody charged with a violent crime earlier than trial, and it could impose money bail or bail bonds on anybody charged with a spread of public-safety or law-and-order offenses,” added the chair of the highly effective Home Oversight Committee.
Rep. Andrew Clyde (R-Ga.) additionally reintroduced a invoice just like one handed by the Home in 2023 that rolled again a bunch of so-called “police reforms” adopted by the Democrat-controlled DC metropolis council the 12 months earlier than. Critics claimed the reforms hamstrung cops’ enforcement capabilities and scrapped their due course of rights.
Norton additionally took difficulty with the measure, claiming it was, like Stefanik’s, “anti-home rule” and that violent crime has already been reduce in half for the reason that final time the Home thought of the same measure.
“Violent crime in DC dropped 35% final 12 months and is down one other 28% this 12 months, but Republicans are performing as if we’re in a disaster that justifies extraordinary federal overreach,” the DC Dem delegate mentioned.
DC nonetheless had the fourth-highest murder-per-capita price of any US metropolis final 12 months, in response to a February 2025 report from the Heart for Public Security Initiatives on the Rochester Institute of Expertise.
Comer mentioned the CLEAN DC Act was an “anti-police legislation” that “stripped legislation enforcement officers of many instruments wanted to execute their duties safely and with out concern of retribution, in addition to restricted their choices in conditions of life or dying.”
“It additionally created new alternatives for anti-police activists to harass legislation enforcement officers and added many undue burdens and necessities to officers within the DC Metropolitan Police Division,” he claimed in his flooring speech.
“By addressing the retention and recruitment crises gripping D.C.’s Metropolitan Police Division, Congress can do its half in serving to enhance the variety of crime fighters this metropolis desperately must maintain violent criminals off the streets,” he mentioned.
Former President Joe Biden vetoed a model of the invoice that handed each chambers of Congress on a bipartisan foundation, claiming it could “overturn commonsense police reforms comparable to: banning chokeholds; limiting use of drive and lethal drive; bettering entry to body-worn digital camera recordings; and requiring officer coaching on de-escalation and use of drive.”
Rep. Andrew Garbarino (R-NY) had additionally championed a invoice rolling again components of that DC legislation in June.
In August, President Trump licensed a federal takeover of Washington that deployed Nationwide Guard troops to wash up — typically actually — the town and use the present of drive to discourage crime, all whereas different federal brokers had been despatched out in a activity drive to grab weapons, medicine and collar perps.
DC Mayor Muriel Bowser — who vetoed her metropolis council’s crime invoice in January 2023 however was later overruled by its members — credited the transfer with decreasing violent crime by 45% by the tip of the month.
Carjackings fell a whopping 87%, and general crime dipped 15%. In September, Bowser ordered native legislation enforcement to cooperate with the feds indefinitely “to the utmost extent allowable by legislation.”
Trump has continued to threaten Democratic localities and jurisdictions utilizing cashless bail with the revocation of federal funds in the event that they refuse to scupper the coverage.
His DC US Legal professional, Jeanine Pirro, has additionally referred to as for the repeal of different soft-on-crime legal guidelines just like the Incarceration Discount Act and the Youth Rehabilitation Modification Act, which permits for sentencing alternate options for younger grownup offenders beneath 22 years of age.
