Filed
12:00 p.m. EDT
08.23.2025
Promising to take over police to struggle crime, Trump’s effort has as an alternative morphed into largely an immigration dragnet.
Pedestrians move D.C. Nationwide Guard troops patrolling Union Station, in Washington, D.C., on Aug. 19, 2025.
That is The Marshall Mission’s Closing Argument e-newsletter, a weekly deep dive right into a key felony justice subject. Need this delivered to your inbox? Join future newsletters.
On Thursday night time, President Donald Trump visited a U.S. Park Police facility in southeast Washington, D.C., turning what was initially billed because the president going “on patrol” right into a a lot much less dramatic affair. He handed out pizza and hamburgers to roughly 300 regulation enforcement personnel, thanking them for his or her work within the metropolis.
It was the newest flip in a virtually two-week odyssey since Trump declared a “public security emergency” within the nation’s capital and invoked rarely-used statutory powers to attempt to override native management of policing and felony justice within the metropolis. The ensuing fallout has included lots of of arrests, and widespread opposition from residents, metropolis leaders and authorized consultants.
Essentially the most unprecedented a part of Trump’s Aug. 11 announcement had a really temporary shelf life. Inside a few day of naming Terry Cole, the administrator of the Drug Enforcement Administration, as “emergency police commissioner,” a federal choose took a skeptical view on whether or not such a transfer could be authorized.
The Division of Justice subsequently rescinded the hassle to take over the Metropolitan Police Division, however secured a concession from metropolis management: full cooperation with federal immigration enforcement. Below the association, Cole can request police help, however doesn’t have command authority over officers.
As a substitute, the takeover has been extra of a parallel federal presence, with the administration flooding the district with nationwide guard personnel, FBI, DEA, ICE and different federal brokers. About 2,000 guardspeople have been deployed, with these numbers buoyed by Nationwide Guard troops despatched from Republican-led states in latest days. Guard members have largely been stationed at federal landmarks and high-traffic areas. Initially, guard personnel have been unarmed, however on Friday, Protection Secretary Pete Hegseth approved arming Nationwide Guard forces patrolling the town.
Roughly 500 federal brokers, in the meantime, have been patrolling neighborhoods on foot, conducting checkpoints, site visitors stops, and immigration enforcement sweeps.
After early experiences from some individuals within the metropolis’s high-crime neighborhoods that not one of the authorities’s acknowledged crime-fighting enthusiasm had made it there, the White Home launched information suggesting that half of all non-immigration arrests throughout the surge had been in high-crime neighborhoods. General there’s a lack of detailed information on who’s arresting whom and for what alleged crimes, however many of the police interactions thus far have been citations and arrests for minor crimes, in line with the native ABC affiliate.
Jeanine Pirro, the U.S. Lawyer for the District, has advised prosecutors in her workplace to hunt most costs in all D.C. arrests, apart from one sudden caveat: This week she introduced her workplace wouldn’t prosecute gun possession instances involving shotguns or rifles, together with AR-style rifles, citing constitutional issues.
In keeping with a number of experiences, the takeover has chilled public exercise within the metropolis. Knowledge from Open Desk confirmed restaurant reservations within the district have been down by as a lot as 31% a day in comparison with final yr throughout the first week of the takeover, then rebounded on Monday, Aug. 18. The dip in exercise was even extra pronounced in immigrant neighborhoods, with one fruit vendor telling The Related Press that enterprise is now worse than throughout the early days of the pandemic.
The president made a lot of false and deceptive claims about crime within the district when explaining the rationale for his takeover effort. These claims have been picked aside intimately by quite a few observers and publications.
D.C. does expertise greater charges of murder, carjacking and armed theft than many different massive American cities, however violent crime has declined considerably over the previous yr by most metrics. Trump has attacked the town and FBI crime statistics as false, citing one MPD commander who has been accused of manipulating statistics. However the division has countered that even when true, such an effort wouldn’t implicate city-wide information — a conclusion shared by a minimum of one crime information knowledgeable.
Many residents of the district do have issues about crime, and have expressed common help for efforts to carry crime charges down, however Trump’s unilateral takeover has been terribly unpopular. In keeping with polling launched this week, almost 80% of residents both considerably or strongly oppose the efforts. The Washington Submit-Schar Faculty ballot additionally discovered that residents really feel much less protected below the takeover than earlier than it.
Immigration enforcement has made up a big a part of the policing surge. As of Tuesday, almost half of the arrests “for the reason that begin of operations” in D.C. have been of undocumented individuals, an administration spokesperson advised The Wall Road Journal. That has been largely pushed by ICE concentrating on areas like bilingual daycare facilities, Spanish-speaking church buildings and site visitors stops to examine the citizenship standing of supply drivers on mopeds.
Some have fearful from the beginning that Trump’s efforts in D.C. is likely to be a costume rehearsal for efforts in different Democratic-led cities — certainly, Trump vaguely threatened as a lot. Others have poured chilly water on that suspicion, declaring that the president has distinctive authorized authority over the district that doesn’t translate elsewhere.
More and more, it appears as if each camps could also be confirmed proper. The president’s management over D.C. is undeniably a particular case, and the hassle to take over the police division there in earnest lasted barely a day. However Democratic leaders throughout the nation fear that parts of the immigration enforcement surge, and the administration’s profitable efforts at bypassing the district’s “sanctuary metropolis” protections, could also be predictive of what the feds will attempt elsewhere, Politico reported this week.
For a lot of commentators, that’s at all times been the purpose. They argue that the surge was by no means about crime, however about Trump projecting dominance — notably over cities which have lengthy resisted his agenda.
“The deployment of out-of-state Nationwide Guard troops and extra federal brokers onto D.C. streets is a brazen abuse of energy meant to intimidate and create concern within the nation’s capital,” stated Monica Hopkins, govt director of the American Civil Liberties Union of the District of Columbia. “That is an pointless overstep to micromanage D.C. below a phony emergency, inflicting actual hurt to residents and guests — all to advance the Trump administration’s political agenda.”
