New York’s leaders are providing badly clashing visions of public security — at a time when cooperation is extra necessary than ever to guard fragile crime wins.
At a Thursday press convention with Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch within the Grand Central Madison subway station, Gov. Kathy Hochul heaped reward onto the NYPD for record-low transit crime, down almost 25% since final 12 months.
Main subway crime is down 14% from pre-pandemic ranges.
That’s a shocking shift from simply final September, when murders within the system have been brushing towards the 25-year excessive set in 2022.
Hochul credited “a surge of law enforcement officials into the subway” as one key purpose for good points, and pledged one other $77 million in state money to cowl cop extra time within the transit system; Tisch in flip cheered, “None of this occurs with out the governor’s investments” into getting officers away from desk jobs and onto platforms and trains.
“This isn’t the time to ease up,” the commish warned: Public transit “should be protected,” and “by the devoted, tireless work of the women and men of the New York Metropolis Police Division, it is going to be protected.”
The core message from each ladies was clear: Extra legislation enforcement equals much less crime, and success drastically is dependent upon leaders being on the identical web page.
But Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani the identical day gave each indication this unity will break the minute he takes workplace, crowing on the Queens Group Home that in his Metropolis Corridor, cops will “now not” be the first responders to calls associated to “a homelessness disaster” or “a mental-health disaster.”
Hmm: Tisch and Hochul lean in on utilizing cops, whereas Mamdani needs to sideline them on two of the greatest causes of subway dysfunction.
Taking the lead as a substitute will likely be civilian workers in his “Division of Group Security,” which Metropolis Councilman Lincoln Restler launched an Eleventh-hour invoice to ascertain.
Mamdani’s obsession with changing officers with social employees jibes with the progressive religion that lowering law-enforcers interplay the general public is a win — nevertheless it’s completely at odds with the values and the extremely profitable strategies of Commissioner Tisch, which have Gov. Hochul’s full-throated assist.
Hochul’s desperate to work with Mamdani, and Tisch has agreed to remain on underneath him; the town wins if the NYPD doesn’t should compromise on the proactive-policing strategy that has produced such spectacular outcomes.
However with zero philosophical coherence between the Mamdani camp and 1 Police Plaza (or the gov), it’s onerous to see any method that occurs — until Mamdani can face information and admit that cops aren’t solely important to public security, however a power for good.
New York’s good points towards crime present that public security improves when leaders in any respect ranges work collectively.
If Mamdani can’t get on board with Tisch’s efficient, confirmed imaginative and prescient for crime-fighting, these wins will likely be the very first thing to go.
