Israel-Hamas peace deal might hinge on return of all Israeli hostage stays, however is that doable?

Metro Loud
9 Min Read


Israel appeared on Wednesday to be limiting the move of humanitarian help into Gaza in response to what it says is Hamas’ delay in handing over the stays of 21 different hostages nonetheless believed to be within the Palestinian territory. Some individuals worry that will not be doable.

An Israeli safety official informed CBS Information on Wednesday that, “opposite to experiences, the Rafah Crossing didn’t open at present,” referring to the important thing portal to Gaza from Egypt, the place tons of help has been stockpiled prepared for supply for weeks. 

The official mentioned preparations had been ongoing for the crossing to open “for the exit and entry of Gazans solely,” however not for help supplies. Nevertheless, the official mentioned an unspecified quantity of help was nonetheless being transported into Gaza by way of the Kerem Shalom crossing, “and different crossings after Israeli safety inspection.”

Calls have mounted for the reason that U.S.-brokered ceasefire took impact on Friday for Israel to permit “full help” into Gaza, as specified below the phrases of President Trump’s 20-point peace plan.

Israeli officers had mentioned that 600 help vehicles per day can be permitted to enter the territory as soon as the U.S.-brokered peace plan took impact. The Israeli authorities has not given particulars on the extent of help site visitors it has allowed by way of since then, however there are experiences that solely half as many vehicles have handed into Gaza every day.

Each the Israeli Hostages and Lacking Households Discussion board, the group which represents the hostage households, and Israel’s protection minister have mentioned the whole peace deal needs to be shelved till the entire hostages’ stays are returned by Hamas.

A person mourns as he leans on a casket coated with an Israeli flag throughout a funeral ceremony for Man Illouz, whose stays had been returned to Israel this week, Oct. 15, 2025, in Rishon LeZion, Israel.

Amir Levy/Getty


The Israel Protection Forces, in a number of statements concerning the return of hostages since Friday, has mentioned solely that “Hamas is required to make all essential efforts to return the deceased hostages.”

Hamas did return 4 extra units of stays on Tuesday night, however the Israeli navy mentioned Wednesday that one in all them was not one of many lacking hostages. 

That might imply the stays of 21 hostages nonetheless lie buried someplace amid the ruins of Gaza, together with greater than 11,000 Gazans who stay lacking, based on the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics. A part of the issue is that a lot of those that oversaw the burial of the deceased hostages at the moment are lifeless themselves.

“Lots of the Hamas commanders who’re liable for burying these Israeli hostages are not alive,” Israeli hostage negotiator Gershon Baskin informed CBS Information on Wednesday. “They had been killed by the Israelis.”

He mentioned there have been nonetheless “hundreds of Gazans who’re unaccounted for, who’re believed to be buried beneath the rubble of the buildings Israel bombed,” too.

Throughout negotiations to seal the Center East peace deal, Hamas representatives mentioned they didn’t know the placement of all of the stays of deceased hostages, based on Israeli media.

Israeli-Palestinian conflict - Khan Younis

A truck carrying gas enters Khan Younis, in southern Gaza, by way of the Karem Shalom crossing as a part of the ceasefire settlement between Israel and Hamas, Oct. 15, 2025.

Abed Rahim Khatib/image alliance/Getty


On the bottom in Gaza, first responders who spent the previous two years dashing in to save lots of lives at the moment are looking for the lifeless. It is a gargantuan job because the Hamas-run territory’s authorities estimates that a minimum of 90% of Gaza’s buildings have been broken or destroyed — and many of the search groups solely have rudimentary instruments.

“They’re simply digging with their fingers,” one man looking for misplaced family members informed CBS Information’ staff Gaza. “We’re exhausted from this and do not have the power anymore.”

He is only one of hundreds of Gazans looking for lacking family members.

“It is very probably that there is likely to be Israeli our bodies beneath the rubble as effectively,” Baskin informed CBS Information. “A few of the deceased hostages might by no means be discovered, and that is a part of the fact, however we have now to make it possible for Hamas is doing every little thing doable to do it.”

“Once I introduced this to the eye of [U.S. senior envoy] Mr. Witkoff final night time, I informed him that is gonna be a difficulty. The Israelis are already screaming that Hamas is breaching the settlement,” Baskin mentioned. “Witkoff mentioned to me, ‘we won’t enable that to occur.’ I do know that the Egyptians have taken this very severely. I perceive that there are some Egyptians who entered Gaza at present to work with Hamas to try to discover the our bodies. This must be resolved, and it must be resolved shortly.”

Trump says “we’ll disarm” Hamas, as group reasserts energy 

The U.S. plan additionally requires an interim governing physique, headed by President Trump, to manage Gaza for an undefined interval earlier than handing over to Palestinian management. However this interim physique has but to be established, and Hamas has already begun to fill the ensuing energy vacuum.

CBS Information has seen armed members of the group again on the streets of Gaza.

Red Cross receives bodies of hostages from Hamas as part of Gaza ceasefire swap

An armed Hamas militant stands guard as a Purple Cross automobile arrives to obtain the our bodies of deceased Israeli hostages, in Gaza Metropolis, Oct. 14, 2025.

Dawoud Abu Alkas/REUTERS


Movies have emerged, which CBS Information has been unable to confirm independently, apparently exhibiting Hamas members executing blindfolded Palestinians accused of collaborating with Israel, in entrance of crowds of individuals. There have additionally been experiences of Hamas attacking rival armed teams and gangs.

“Hamas is killing them as a result of it may possibly,” Baskin informed CBS Information. “Israel has empowered, with weapons and cash, gangs of Palestinians who had been concerned in principally unlawful actions previously … they usually’ve empowered them as an alternative choice to Hamas.”

President Trump reacted to the movies on Tuesday, saying just lately that Hamas “did take out a few gangs, that had been very dangerous gangs, very, very dangerous … and that did not trouble me a lot to be sincere with you.”

“However we have now informed them we need to disarm and they’ll disarm,” Mr. Trump mentioned. “And if they do not disarm, we’ll disarm them, and it will occur shortly and maybe violently.”

Adm. Brad Cooper, the commander of the U.S. navy’s Central Command, urged Hamas on Wednesday to “instantly droop violence and taking pictures at harmless Palestinian civilians in Gaza — in each Hamas-held elements of Gaza and people secured by the IDF [Israeli military] behind the Yellow Line.”

“That is an historic alternative for peace. Hamas ought to seize it by absolutely standing down, strictly adhering to President Trump’s 20-point peace plan, and disarming at once,” Cooper mentioned in an announcement shared on social media. “We now have conveyed our considerations to the mediators who agreed to work with us to implement the peace and shield harmless Gaza civilians. We stay extremely optimistic for the way forward for peace within the area.” 

Share This Article