A murderous couple who hacked up two housemates with meat cleavers after which scattered their heads and different severed stays throughout Lengthy Island confessed to the grisly horror in court docket Tuesday.
Jeffrey Mackey, 40, was spared a life jail sentence, as a substitute receiving 22 years behind bars, after he claimed he was abused by the victims, whereas his girlfriend Alexis Nieves, 35, landed 11 years as a part of plea offers.
“Whereas the crimes that had been dedicated had been violent and tragic — justice on this case required balancing accountability for the hurt triggered with recognition of the documented abuse historical past which we can’t touch upon,” Suffolk County District Lawyer Ray Tierney stated in a press release.
The killers confessed to murdering and chopping up Malcolm Craig Brown, 53, and his spouse Donna Conneely, 59, within the Amityville dwelling all of them shared in 2024.
Nieves smashed Conneely within the head with a meat tenderizer — kicking the lady as she choked on her personal blood — whereas Mackey fatally stabbed Brown.
Mackey and Nieves then joined up with two different housemates to chop up the our bodies with meat cleavers — a job so ugly that the drains, bogs, sinks and showers in the home turned choked with blood and a few of the stays.
The remainder of the victims’ physique components had been discovered over the span of every week in late February and early March 2024, scattered throughout Southards Pond Park in Babylon, wooded areas in West Babylon and all through Bethpage State Park, in accordance with police.
The primary discovery got here when a gaggle of highschool college students stumbled onto what turned out to be Brown’s severed arms whereas strolling to class.
Police then discovered two severed heads in the identical park later that day, prompting hypothesis that the Lengthy Island gang MS-13 could possibly be accountable.
At Tuesday’s listening to, Mackey’s attorneys, Anthony La Pinta and Mark Cohen, submitted to the choose a forensic psychiatric report detailing the abuse Mackey allegedly endured, in accordance with Newsday.
Prosecutors stated Suffolk Supreme Courtroom Justice John Collins referenced the findings in his ruling, however the 28-page report itself has been sealed, in accordance with the court docket.
The Home Violence Survivors Justice Act, handed in 2019, lets judges hand down lighter sentences to domestic-violence survivors if they’ll present the abuse performed a significant position within the crime, in accordance with the state’s Workplace of Indigent Authorized Providers.
A 3rd couple who lived within the Amityville home, considered one of whom is Brown’s cousin — Steven Brown, 46 — and Amanda Wallace, 42, already pleaded responsible in September to felony expenses tied to dumping the stays and to a theft dedicated every week earlier.
All 4 responsible housemates admitted they dismembered and dumped the our bodies to maintain police from investigating the deaths, which occurred one week after Brown and Wallace helped Mackey perform a knifepoint theft at a Valero fuel station in Copiague.
That very same knife was used to homicide and dismember Brown and Conneely.
As a part of his plea deal final 12 months, Steven Brown admitted he served as a lookout for Mackey at Valero and is ready to obtain 5 years in jail for first-degree theft.
Wallace is predicted to serve two years in jail.
All 4 are scheduled to be sentenced Jan. 13.
